Tar Sand in the Eyes

Michael Lynch, a so-called energy consultant who used to be involved in energy research at MIT’s Center for International Studies, has a silly little piece of specious reasoning in today’s New York Times. The point of Lynch’s article is that the widespread belief in the  “peak oil” theory is leading to wasting money investing in “hairbrained renewable energy schemes” and imposing “unnecessary and expensive conservation measures.” 

Of course, Lynch never gives a single example of a “harebrained”  scheme or of unnecessary conservation, preferring to spend his limited words on attempting to demonstrate that the earth has 2.5 trillion barrels of oil and not a mere 2 trillion as claimed by some “peak oil” advocates.  As Wikipedia tells us, the peak theory, first proposed by M. King Hubbert, is a mathematical way to determine when the production of petroleum from any given oil field peaks, after which the yield from the field will start to dwindle inevitably to nothing. 

Let’s say that all of the adjustments that Lynch proposes to make to the peak oil theory are accurate and appropriate:  Won’t we still  run out of oil one day?  Are we better off sticking our hands in the tar sands (from which oil companies hope to one day pull oil) because we have more oil than one set of engineers say we do?  And isn’t the burning of oil for fuel still a major cause of global warming?

The interesting part of the article of course is the sly way in which by changing the argument from “when will we run out of oil” to “have we reached what can technically be described as the ‘peak’ in possible oil production,” Lynch hopes to justify less regulation and less investment in a viable energy future.  It’s an old rhetorical trick, akin to throwing (tar) sand into the eyes of the reader. 

opedge
8 comments on “Tar Sand in the Eyes
  1. kalkulator ac says:

    Generally speaking… I do not agree with that.

  2. full movies online free says:

    Thank you for this fantastic Article. Great topic to talk about on my site. I may set a bookmark to your blog.

  3. chat forum says:

    Good day, just needed you to know I have added your website to my Google bookmarks as a consequence of your extraordinary blog layout. But seriously, I do think your blog has one of the freshest theme I’ve ran into. It really makes reading your blog easier.

  4. Buy Backlinks says:

    This is a good blog. Keep up all the work. I too love to blog. This is great everyone sharing opinions 🙂

  5. Denice Marmol says:

    Great site!!!

  6. newspaper says:

    dispenses employ a good web site decent Gives with thanks for the effort to guide everyone

  7. I believe that peak oil is accurate and that we are now past the point of peak oil. I understand many of the current events have to do with this senerio and it won’t be long before the main stream media and population wake up and understand what is going on. For me and my family, we are preparing for the next generation.

  8. Video Game says:

    I’m not big on commenting, but nice post. I always found good quality information from this site! I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AlphaOmega Captcha Classica  –  Enter Security Code
     
 

*

14 − 7 =