Believers that Obama is socialist, Muslim and anti-Christ use false evidence and illogical reasoning.

I usually don’t analyze the comments people leave on my blog, mainly because there is usually nothing much to say except, “Thanks for the kind words.”  I do want to spend a few paragraphs looking at what someone named Tom Snyder wrote about my entry of March 24 in which I share the results of a Louis Harris survey that finds that two-thirds of all Republicans think the President is a socialist, 57 percent think he’s a Muslim and 24 percent say “he may be the anti-Christ.”

Here is what Mr. Snyder writes about my statement that none of these assertions about our President are true: This is baloney. Castro just praised Obama-Care. And, he wants Obama’s cap and trade bill and amnesty for illegal aliens passed. Finally, there is indeed a notation on Obama’s school records showing his step-father considered him a Muslim. According to Islam, you cannot renounce the Muslim faith once you accept it. And, the fact that Obama went to a heretical black liberation church for 20 years proves that he’s not really a Christian. There is no one Anti-Christ, but Obama’s big government, pro-abortion policies reflect the national socialist policies of the Beast in the Book of Revelation, who IS an Anti-Christ.”

Let’s deconstruct Mr. Snyder’s evidence that Obama is a socialist, a Muslim and possibly the anti-Christ, beginning with his proof that President Obama is a socialist: “Castro just praised Obama-Care. And, he wants Obama’s cap and trade bill and amnesty for illegal aliens passed.” I guess that means that if Castro is in favor of flush toilets, anyone who uses them is a socialist.  My point, of course, is that just because someone who calls himself a socialist likes a political position that does not mean that everyone who holds that position is a socialist. 

If we pick at Snyder’s statements a little more closely, we discover more logical flaws: 1) Obama-Care has no public option, as a socialist law would have, but instead delivers some 30 million new customers to private insurance companies, just as mandating automobile insurance decades ago created millions of new customers for car insurance carriers. 2) “Cap-and-trade” is a way to regulate a free market (capitalism) without actually infringing on the right of companies to pollute, whereas a socialist solution to global warming would have the government take over industries. 3) It is absurd to call amnesty for illegal aliens a socialist position, because socialism describes an economic system, whereas amnesty for illegal aliens is a tactic for dealing with a social problem.  A laissez-faire capitalist could just as readily believe in amnesty without contradiction.

Let’s move on to Mr. Snyder’s evidence that our President is a Muslim: “…there is indeed a notation on Obama’s school records showing his step-father considered him a Muslim. According to Islam, you cannot renounce the Muslim faith once you accept it.”  Even if it were true that the President’s step-father once described Obama as a Muslim, that does not mean that the President ever considered himself a Muslim.  And even if as a youth Obama for a time considered himself to be Muslim or followed some Islamic practices, that does not mean he is caught in the Muslim identity forever, no matter what some set of Islamic religious leaders decided was religious law several centuries ago.  I am going to infer from his remarks and the fact that his link leads back to a Christian family movie-rating website that Mr. Snyder is a devout Christian. As a Christian, he should 1) believe in the concept of being reborn, which means anyone, including a Muslim or an African-American, can change one’s spots and become a different, “better” person; and 2) reject the authority of the Islamic religion, which means that the fact that Islamic law says you can’t renounce the faith has no bearing on how a Christian determines if someone is a Muslim or not.

More evidence that Mr. Snyder finds that our President is Muslim: “And, the fact that Obama went to a heretical black liberation church for 20 years proves that he’s not really a Christian.” Of course the black liberation church is Christian, but even if it were not, not being Christian does not make you Muslim.

I want to point out that the very fact that President Obama’s religion is an issue reflects an odious racism.  What would be wrong if he were a Muslim?  The ideological subtext behind the discussion is that being a Muslim is by definition a bad thing.  It reflects the belief by some such as Samuel Huntington that we are in a holy war with Islam.  I reject this analysis of current events as a racist excuse for launching wars to control natural resources.  But I will admit that for someone who believes in the holy war theory, it would be important to know who is and isn’t a Muslim.  But that “need to know” doesn’t make someone whose views you don’t like a Muslim.

Finally, let’s consider Mr. Snyder’s evidence that our President may be an anti-Christ: “There is no one Anti-Christ, but Obama’s big government, pro-abortion policies reflect the national socialist policies of the Beast in the Book of Revelation, who IS an Anti-Christ.”  Revelations is a cryptic document with lots of symbolism and fanciful language, leaving it as much open to interpretation as a book of prediction or a manual for explaining current events.  Words and phrases such as “big government,” “abortion” and “national socialism” are nowhere to be found in it.  Mr. Snyder and others can believe whatever they want to believe about the interpretation of Revelations.  It’s a great leap of logic, however, to state that someone is an anti-Christ because of a belief in positions that someone says that Revelations says are held by an allegorical figure.  By that definition, every mild anti-Semite is and was a Nazi, and we know that’s not true.

Mr. Snyder has every right to oppose the political positions held by our President and to fight against the President and his positions on the battlefield of ideas.  But saying the President is a socialist, Muslim and anti-Christ is just name-calling and nothing more.  Most of us have been brainwashed since birth to fear and hate socialism and to revere Christianity, and some of us reverted to an ugly racism in the wake of 9/11 by conflating what a small group of radicals did with the faith of a billion people.  Many therefore react emotionally when we hear someone called these terms.  Labeling has long been a cheap tactic used by political propagandists to make people dislike people and positions.  Labeling helped to turn back the tide of the progressive movement before and during World War I.  During the McCarthy era, labeling of people as communists instilled fear into the entire country.  

And labeling still works, as we can see from the Louis Harris survey that found that so many people apply these labels falsely to our President.  It sad and dangerous when name-calling replaces a logical discussion of the issues.  It’s just as disheartening though that people get away with the illogical justifications for name-calling that Mr. Snyder gives.

opedge
24 comments on “Believers that Obama is socialist, Muslim and anti-Christ use false evidence and illogical reasoning.
  1. Under ObamaCare pizzas will get to your house faster than an ambulances.

  2. The right wing nuts are going losing steam. People are evolving. The right wing is not.

  3. Dario Arashiro says:

    Sure, but that money shift happened a long time ago, nothing new there. Republicans could introduce legislation on Social Security, sure. Some kind of legislation may even be needed. But, they don’t call that a third rail for nothing. They found that out when Bush tried to privatize Social Security, just like Paul Ryan wants to do. Not only will something like that not pass, the pitchforks will be sharpened.

  4. Alonso Mozier says:

    The President has quit on healthcare public option, tax cuts for the wealthy, and housing starts by the Israeli. Obama needs to quit paying attention to the Clintons, Bidens, and others as to behavioral politics and do the right thing.

  5. Janean Froebe says:

    I have read nearly all the posts on your blog and I would to continue but I terribly want to sleep. It’s 4 a.m.

  6. Marleen Siles says:

    Brilliant and well deserved! Enjoy the moment and the prize!

  7. Guillermo Brimm says:

    If this comment doesnt appear after reading all those instructions Im sending a carrier pigeon next

  8. Gruenber says:

    I had difficulty looking at this in Firefox but it works fine in IE. Anway, the content is good. I am very happy to have come across this.

  9. Endersbe says:

    Hi! I saw your blog at Google and have learned a lot from it. Thank you very much for the useful and detailed posts. Will be coming back soon.

  10. Dane Marcin says:

    but I thought you could tell me how to do that!! 😉

  11. Wyman Joneston says:

    Cons are mad about Obama's trip because there are no spoils involved with diplomacy.

  12. usauto says:

    To the point and well written, tyvm for the post

  13. Trebil106 says:

    Straightforward and well written, I appreciate for the info

  14. sym says:

    Concise and well written, tyvm for the information

  15. Bryce Monje says:

    You…are…my…hero!!! I cant believe something like this exists on the internet! Its so true, so honest, and more than that you dont sound like an idiot! Finally, someone who knows how to talk about a subject without sounding like a kid who didnt get that bike he wanted for Christmas

  16. arthritis-nutrition says:

    Your Website is very useful. Thank you so much for providing plenty of practical content. I will bookmark your blog siteand will be without doubt coming back. Once again, I appreciate all your work and also providing a lot good tricks for your readers.

  17. wilmington flat fee real estate says:

    Well said, I could not agree more with you on this issue. I think your blog is very popular on this topic judging by all the other comments posted to it. I just wanted to leave a comment to appreciate your hard work.

  18. Pick Up Artist Forum PUA says:

    Good stuff. Appreciate it…

  19. George Snyder says:

    Hmm, that’s interesting. I would search on Google to find other relevant information. Actually, I came across your blog on Google Blog Search. I’m going to add your RSS feed to my reader. Continue posting please!

  20. Karl Riebel says:

    Thanks for this interesting information.

  21. I commonly don’t article in Blogs but your web site forced me to, amazing perform.. beautiful

  22. What would happen if we took his perspective seriously?

  23. The first step in any conversation is showing a desire to create real dialogue. I’m confident we are making progress in our opinions.

  24. Thanks! This is probably the most interesting info I have found on this subject on the net.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

nineteen − thirteen =