The argument by anecdote: every demagogue’s best friend

Argument by anecdote is when you prove a point with a story.  It is a very compelling argument, because people like stories about other people more than they like cold, hard facts.   Too often, though, the argument by anecdote is used when the facts are stacked heavily against a position.  If you don’t have the facts, tell a story.  People will believe the anecdote because it demonstrates what they themselves believe to be true.  That’s why you’ll find more arguments by anecdotes proffered by those on the losing end of the “facts” battle.

It worked for Reagan, with his tales of welfare queens and small businesses frustrated by big government.  In a way, the “Willie Horton” ads of Bush Sr. were an argument by anecdote because studies have always shown that early parole invariably works to bring down the rate of recidivism; it just didn’t in this one anecdote.

If you listen carefully for arguments by anecdotes in what Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck say, you will find that, like most demagogues, they both make frequent use of them to support their positions.  For both, the argument by anecdote often takes the place of a racial stereotype or statement, especially when discussing poor people, Moslems or President Obama.

Now I’m bringing up the argument by anecdote for a reason.  There was a classic if crude example at the beginning of a weirdly disjointed article by columnist Ralph Reiland, which I saw in the November 16 issue of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

First the facts, here are reports of four of the many recent studies that have concluded that the U.S. takes worse care of its citizens than other industrialized nations and charges them more to do so.  Our infant mortality rate is higher, we die on average at a younger age, our doctors don’t send as many preventive reminders to patients, fewer of our doctors use electronic medical records, we pay more for health care…on and on and on it goes, a sad litany of surveys that show we spend the most and get the least in the way of health care: 

Now Mr. Reiland believes that the U.S. health care system is the best in the world and that the health care systems in other countries such as England are disasters.  The facts are against him, though, so he resorts to an anecdote of someone living in Great Britain who had two appendectomies in one month and is now in constant pain.  There is no explanation, as Reiland fills the second half of his column with other topics. 

But no explanation is needed.  By this time, people of all views understand that an anecdote about health care in Britain or Canada will likely be about a disaster and will be a living, breathing testament to the fact that we in the U.S. can thank our lucky stars that we have our healthcare system and not that of these other nations.

32 thoughts on “The argument by anecdote: every demagogue’s best friend

  1. This Rangel thing is a joke. Censure is not strong enough. He needs to be punished. Removed from office. Done. Do you think you or I would get off with a slap on the wrists as this is?

  2. Hey there! I’d like to say that I love all your posting style and that so I want to visit this blog regularly from now 🙂 Keep it up!

  3. You certainly deserve a round of applause for your post and more specifically, your blog in general. Very high quality material.

  4. Eighty percent of the people who call themselves Democrats don’t have a clue as to political reality. What amazes me is that you could take a group of people who are hard workers and convince them that they should support social programs that were the exact opposite of their own personal convictions. Put a little fear here and there and you can get people to vote any way you want.

  5. Although I would’ve preferred if you went into a little bit more detail, I still got the gist of what you meant. I agree with it. It might not be a popular idea, but it makes sense. Will definitely come back for more of this. Great work

  6. Although I would’ve preferred if you went into a little bit more detail, I still got the gist of what you meant. I agree with it. It might not be a popular idea, but it makes sense. Will definitely come back for more of this. Great work

  7. Although I would’ve preferred if you went into a little bit more detail, I still got the gist of what you meant. I agree with it. It might not be a popular idea, but it makes sense. Will definitely come back for more of this. Great work

  8. Once and for all a great post in relation to the topic, continue the great work and I wish to read much more from you in the long run.

  9. Cool, there are in fact some good points on this article a few of my visitors may find this useful, I’ll post a link, thanks.

  10. Thanks so much for your wonderful website;this is the words that keeps me on track through out my day. I’ve been searching around for this site after asked to visit them from a colleague and was pleased when I found it after searching for some time. Being a avid blogger, I’m hopeful to see others taking initivative and contributing to the community. Just wanted to comment to show my appreciation for your work as it is very encouraging, and many bloggers do not get acknowledgment they deserve. I am sure I’ll be back and will send some of my friends.

  11. Someone I work with visits your blog frequently and recommended it to me to read also. The writing style is great and the content is interesting. Thanks for the insight you provide the readers!

  12. I have read other blogs along the same topic as yours but none have really been as detailed. I really appreciate your thought you put into it. It really shows. Thanks again.

  13. I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

  14. Took me time to be able to examine most the remarks, however I really appreciated the write-up. It turned out to be Really helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here as well! It’s definitely great when you can not merely be enlightened, but additionally entertained! I’m positive you had fun writing this article.

  15. I am against most of what Obama stands for, but on this he is right. When we begin to disregard the basic principles of our constitution, we are handing the terrorists a major victory. We must understand that the vast majority of Muslims are good moral people. The extremists are the ones causing the damage and they are a disgrace to most Muslims. Christians have had their extremists as well…..think of the loonies who protest at soldiers funerals, the KKK, and other Christian Militant groups. It would be ashame to let these fringe groups define the Christian Identity. We should not let that happen to those of other religions either for it will, eventually, come full circle!!!

  16. I don’t frequently agree with the comments that are presented on blogs but in this case I agree.

  17. I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am starting a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.

  18. I love your blog! did you create this yourself or did you outsource it? Im looking for a blog design thats similar so thats the only reason I’m asking. Either way keep up the nice work I was impressed with your content really..

  19. Anecdotes can be powerful and effective tools, but only when they support facts. When they replace facts and go counter to the facts at hand, then it’s propaganda.

  20. At workshops on grant support and fund raising for non-profits, all that I have been told lately is “Skip the boring facts and statistics, tell a human story.” And folks are taught to tell a compelling story – mine must be more compelling/sympathetic than yours to get the money. So perhaps the anecdote has become everybody’s best friend, including those who purportedly wear the white hats.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *