USDA food pyramid elongates as much as Pinocchio’s nose and for pretty much the same reason.

The people who make advertising decisions for the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) must either have a sick sense of humor or an unconscious desire to admit that they’ve twisted the purpose of the food pyramid from helping people make good eating decisions to supporting food manufacturers.

The USDA is now running a series of public service announcement TV spots in which following the food pyramids help Pinocchio to grow into a real boy. 

The idea of using a pyramid to represent the ideal in healthy eating is brilliant in concept:  A pyramid is a series of triangular blocks one piled on top of the next, with each successively higher one smaller.  The food pyramid uses the lower blocks to represent food groups like carbohydrates of which people should eat more and higher blocks to represent to represent the food groups like meat of which people should eat less.  Look at the pyramid and you know exactly how to eat a healthy diet.

But as Marc Bittman (whom I trashed for his Thanksgiving anxiety piece in the New York Times) accurately points out in Food Matters, the food pyramid was tainted from its first public appearance as a USDA communications tool in 1992.  Although the first pyramid did get all the proportions right (6-11 daily servings of carbs; 2-4 or fruit; 3-5 of vegetables; only 2-3 from the vast group comprising meat, nuts, poultry, beans and eggs and sparing use of fats and sugar), nowhere did the pyramid mention that the carbs should all be whole-grain.  Bittman notes that it would thus be possible for someone to eat only highly refined carbohydrates, which metabolize like the sugar we are advised to avoid.  Bad for people, but good for food processors.

Today’s pyramid is a disgusting depiction of how special interests can sabotage the public interest.  Instead of blocks that use the pyramid’s shape to symbolize nutritional eating, the pyramid comprises a series of vertical bands, some slightly thicker and some slightly thinner, extending from the base to the apex of the pyramid.  We are supposed to eat less of the food from the thinner bands, but it’s so hard to tell the difference. 

But in fact the visual impact of the pyramid structure is completely lost.  The branding power of being able to see shapes that have immediate meaning is completely lost.  Instead we have a cheerfully colorful geometrical form that tells us nothing about nutrition.  We can of course read the fine print by clicking on the various bands, but instead of seeing in one image a strategy for healthy eating, we instead get a collection of unrelated factoids.

There are all kinds of lies, including lies by omission, by careful selection and pruning of facts, by false comparisons (conflations), by changing the subject to something irrelevant, or in the case of the food pyramid by the placement of facts on the page.  Saying that the combination of food groups we should eat has a pyramidal relationship to each other and then arranging the pyramid to conceal that relationship is a form of lying to my mind very similar to saying that refined sugar is natural or touting fat content for foods as a means to pretend that it makes them good for dieting.

In short, the USDA is a puppet for food processors.  And we all know what happens to the noses of puppets like Pinocchio when they lie. 

11 comments on “USDA food pyramid elongates as much as Pinocchio’s nose and for pretty much the same reason.
  1. Linda Elis says:

    Since the quality of treatment within the Universal technique is so bad you certainly tend not to prefer to have to use it. Therefore you’ll live longer by taking greater care of yourself.

  2. Randell Klitzner says:

    Very good stuff.

  3. Sterback says:

    the food pyramid always calls for low fat high fiber diets, that is why i always stick into it `:*

  4. Thomasine Benedix says:

    The doc should have told you what to avoid.

  5. deep says:

    I dont usually comment but i have to tell you well done

  6. Bartley7 says:

    the food pyramid always calls for low carb and high protein diet but ease up on dairy products as well*;,

  7. Janay Baetz says:

    I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of info that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this beneficial content.

  8. Reinaldo Nip says:

    Skimming through this text I have discovered answers for number of questions that have been troubling me for long time now. Its problematic to find accurate publications on the web as many such articles are invented by a person with ignorant of the topic. Your text is unique and definitively worth recommending. I’m coming back to read more of your texts in some time.

  9. Larry Jay says:

    I was very happy to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

  10. Hi, Very interesting article. I am quite impressed and just wanted to let you know that you did a fine job on this article. However, I do have some unanswered questions that I would like to ask you. I will contact you via email so that you can clear some of these things up for me. Again, very well written article. Keep up the good work.

  11. human growth says:

    Your post has been more than helpful. I just started a blog and I’m not getting any traffic at all. Can you help me out? Thanks Dave

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


8 + 19 =